The Chain of Command Is a Semantic Shredder
The 1854 Filter: Footwear and the Crimean Front
In the winter of , a low-level clerk in the British War Office named Arthur Penhaligon sat at a scarred mahogany desk and processed a stack of frantic, handwritten notes from the Crimean front.
One note, scribbled by a captain in the 17th Lancers, was particularly specific: the new shipment of cavalry boots featured a decorative buckle that caught on the stirrup during a mount, causing riders to lose their footing at the exact moment they needed to be most secure. It was a small flaw, a minor oversight in a mass-production contract.
Arthur read it, nodded, and placed it in a bin for “Equipment Review.” Two weeks later, his superior, a man who had never seen a horse in battle, summarized the bin’s contents into a one-page memo. The memo mentioned “minor aesthetic adjustments to footwear.”
By the time that memo reached the procurement board, the line was deleted to save space for a discussion on the price of grain. The next order of 5,000 boots was placed, buckle and all, and men continued to fall under their horses’ hooves.
The decay of specific detail as information ascends the hierarchy.
The Chain of Command Is a Semantic Shredder Read More »
